Friday, September 26, 2008

Reverse Osmosis

Of late I have been meeting foreigners – various nationalities; each one of them finds it astounding that people speak more of English than any of the native languages in Mumbai. I try to tell them that we learn it as first language in school, so we are used to it. They still don't see why we can't talk in hindi among ourselves. Since these encounters I have consciously tried to keep track of conversations I have with people. I have found that very few educated people will reply or talk to you in Hindi or Marathi. Ask a question in Hindi or Marathi and 99 out of 100 times the reply will be in English. Some people just refuse to speak anything else. No wonder so many English speaking classes have sprouted in the city.

One of my friend teaches in one such institute in the western suburbs. Recently I went to meet her at her class and she asked me to talk to the students and give them some tips on how to prepare for interviews. I asked each one of them why did they want to learn to speak English. Everybody believed that English was the key to profesional success. One guy said he works in the purchase department of a company and finds it difficult to communicate with people as many talk to him in English. He stated because he studied in vernacular medium his English is weak and he wants to improve it. I have never liked the word vernacular. I said to him Marathi is not vernacular it is far superior in syntax and structure than English. It is nice to learn English though, it is the most dynamic and inclusive language and much help in the professional world. It is amazing how this term 'Vernacular' has become synonymous with Indian Languages. A bunch of arrogant colonists term some of the richest languages in the history of humankind in terms of both literature and dialect as vernacular and Indians continue to be the torchbearers of a dead past. Allow me a chuckle here.

It is amazing how the English dailies unfailingly use this umbrella term every time they have to refer to any Indian Language. Now since English has become as much Indian as any other language why still the distinction. Can't do much about our psuedo-intellectual, elitist media, they are best left alone. But what's stopping me from having fun. It's time for reverse osmosis (don't ask me what it is, I like the term). I am going to work the ask me anything in English and I will reply in Hindi trick on everybody. And if someone throws a fake accent devil help them.

7 comments:

A Chrysanthemum by any other name... said...

well i cant help noticing that this blog is still in english

Anonymous said...

Oi Angrez Kahikiii !!! Gaawd ! I'm tyyred of yeww desis

Cheeyaars :P
M

PS: I have spoken more Hindi /Marathi/Malayalam over here than back in India. Strange na ?

Anonymous said...

well...even in dubai all the indians(almost)like to communiucate in english only rather than hindi.

Flying Machine said...

Chrys: I love English! This post is not about English. It is about people's condescending attitude. How something is considered "The Thing" and anything else is looked down upon. This attitude is not just limited to language, but is applied to everything else under the sun, from way of dressing to eating to choice of a spouse. I love languages so I wrote about it.

Anks said...

bravo,

what a post.... remember the late eighties / early nineties when speaking fluent english was a matter of superiority?

I have realised that the Chinese & Japanese professionals maintain documents in their own language even in MNCs. They even sign in their own script. Does that make them any less efficient (on that front) than their Indian counterparts? I agree that knowing English gives you an edge in the global arena, but letting that give rise to a contempt for your own language? Thats ridiculous. Why can't we be proud of our heritage?

hmmm.... me just rambling on...

Anonymous said...

a few days ago, we were at an iftar at ziaka, an indian rest and being indian, i was chosen to place the order for the group. I started with english and slowly dropped in hindi -- and that brought out a comment that mostly they hear indian people talk to indian people in english, but i prefer hindi, i like beign the desi :):)

in fact on my first visit paris, in the mall, they woudlnt help me if i spoke in english, but then i put on the hindi, and they asked me if i know english and everythign went like maska... !! hehe.. Hindi is powerful.. bery bery powerful and though the statement is made in english -- Hindi Rules. !! (so does the million other indian languages )

Anonymous said...

Karzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
whoever makes fun of the spelling will be asked to spell it in the hindi script...with the extra 'Z's

(Yawn)Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz